Frank Herbert believed Star Wars copied Dune

George Lucas likely never settled that dinner debt with Frank Herbert. The comparison between Star Wars and Herbert’s Dune is not merely a passing observation; it’s a saga of intertwined influences and occasional friction. Just as the mystical teachings of the Bene Gesserit spread across the universe of Dune, so too did the impact of Herbert’s epic tale permeate the landscape of science fiction.

In the vast expanse of the genre, some works subtly incorporate elements inspired by Dune, weaving them seamlessly into their narratives. Others, however, wear their homage to Herbert’s masterpiece unabashedly, sometimes to the point of distraction. And then there’s Star Wars, a cinematic phenomenon that stands as perhaps the most blatant echo of Dune, at least according to Frank Herbert himself.

Before his passing in 1986, Herbert sparingly commented on George Lucas’ groundbreaking film, yet his remarks hinted at a nuanced reaction to its similarities with Dune. In a revealing 1977 interview with the Associated Press, Herbert acknowledged the uncanny resemblances between Star Wars and his own series. He noted the shared motifs, such as the presence of characters like Princess Alia and Princess Leia, and the striking parallels in setting, including the presence of sandworm carcasses and desert-dwelling cultures.

Despite the undeniable influences from various sources that shaped Star Wars, Herbert couldn’t help but feel a twinge of suspicion regarding the extent of its parallels to Dune. His 1985 speech at UCLA reflected this sentiment, as he highlighted sixteen points of identity between the two narratives, questioning the statistical improbability of such similarities arising purely by chance.

The frustration evident in Herbert’s remarks stemmed from a longstanding jest he maintained about Lucas owing him dinner for the remarkable convergence of themes and motifs. This ongoing banter between the two visionary creators underscored Herbert’s ambivalence towards the undeniable echoes of Dune in the Star Wars universe.

However, Herbert was not one to dwell solely on grievances. In a masterstroke of literary finesse, he subtly nodded to Star Wars within the pages of his novel Heretics of Dune. Buried within its rich tapestry of narrative threads, a passage emerged that bore a striking resemblance to elements of the Star Wars mythology. While Herbert never officially confirmed this as a deliberate homage, the allusion left readers speculating about the depth of cross-pollination between the two iconic franchises.

Thus, the legacy of Dune lives on not only in its expansive universe but also in the echoes reverberating through the corridors of science fiction history. The relationship between Dune and Star Wars serves as a testament to the enduring power of storytelling, where inspiration and homage intertwine to shape the landscape of imagination for generations to come.

We bring out some of the most well-known Star wars collection, all of which are available at reasonable costs. Visit our link now if you are interested in the Star wars collection

Luke Skywalker, Leia Organa, Han Solo, Chewbacca, Obi-Wan Kenobi